|
Post by adamme on Oct 23, 2016 18:59:02 GMT -5
I haven't been through the thread, but just finished watching the video of XFactor. This is what I think! Sorry that one person from each judge has to go. There are several that will make it through because of this. I don't think any of Adam's group should go . . . but, having to choose, I choose to say goodbye to Isiah. He shouldn't have to leave! From Mel's group, it should be Maddie. From Iggy's group, goodbye to the four guys who made the boy group. I can't even remember their name. From Guy, goodbye to Tim. I don't think any from Adam's group should go. But this is how the game is played! Can't believe I'm paying so much attention to this show . . . nothing like this since 2009. It's all because of Adam, of course - but I have to say that I'm impressed with intelligent comments from all judges. Adam's decision to have Amalia play the piano as she sang was genius! The only critique I really disagree with was Mel's about Amalia. I think her critique was set up to lose votes for Amalia. Sorry Ivy wasn't chosen. IMO, she should have been singing, instead of Maddie. Well, this has been two hours of RL that I'll never get back! Time to make dinner . . . I almost agree with all the singers you picked. I cannot make up my mind for Adam's group. I love them all and so does Adam. However, I think Amalia's an amazing singer, very talented and sings beautifully but she will sing the same way every time. Agree on Mel's and Guy's group. I think from Iggy's group it will be the Brentwoods.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Location:
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 23, 2016 19:01:12 GMT -5
I agree....but isn't it Maddie that has a big youtube following? If so then Mel B is likely counting on that vote getter...I may be wrong on that...good ole memory ain't what it used to be LOL She does? In any case Mel B should be really picking contestents for her live shows who are ready to go, not potential. Like Adam was on idol. I agree with Adam, Maddie never really connected with the audience, Ivy connected massively haha, but none of it matters now. Well on Xfactors page on YT, Ivy has more views then Maddy, so dunno. I seem to remember Maddie and MelB have a connection/relationship back to Maddie being on some youth star show. Just enough memory to get me in trouble, I expect. :-)
|
|
|
Post by adamme on Oct 23, 2016 19:02:11 GMT -5
I haven't been through the thread, but just finished watching the video of XFactor. This is what I think! Sorry that one person from each judge has to go. There are several that will make it through because of this. I don't think any of Adam's group should go . . . but, having to choose, I choose to say goodbye to Isiah. He shouldn't have to leave! From Mel's group, it should be Maddie. From Iggy's group, goodbye to the four guys who made the boy group. I can't even remember their name. From Guy, goodbye to Tim. I don't think any from Adam's group should go. But this is how the game is played! Can't believe I'm paying so much attention to this show . . . nothing like this since 2009. It's all because of Adam, of course - but I have to say that I'm impressed with intelligent comments from all judges. Adam's decision to have Amalia play the piano as she sang was genius! The only critique I really disagree with was Mel's about Amalia. I think her critique was set up to lose votes for Amalia. Sorry Ivy wasn't chosen. IMO, she should have been singing, instead of Maddie. Well, this has been two hours of RL that I'll never get back! Time to make dinner . . . Gotta agree with you on every point. But I think Vladi needs to go. Toss up b etween Maddie and Vladie There're so many great singers in each group, but I'm afraid that Australia will vote for "cuteness/Vlado' instead of great voices.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Location:
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 23, 2016 19:02:34 GMT -5
She does? In any case Mel B should be really picking contestents for her live shows who are ready to go, not potential. Like Adam was on idol. I agree with Adam, Maddie never really connected with the audience, Ivy connected massively haha, but none of it matters now. Well on Xfactors page on YT, Ivy has more views then Maddy, so dunno. I seem to remember Maddie and MelB have a connection/relationship back to Maddie being on some youth star show. Just enough memory to get me in trouble, I expect. :-) I remember that info too
|
|
3ku1
Member
Posts: 3,009
Location:
|
Post by 3ku1 on Oct 23, 2016 19:06:55 GMT -5
I seem to remember Maddie and MelB have a connection/relationship back to Maddie being on some youth star show. Just enough memory to get me in trouble, I expect. :-) I remember that info too So its a conflict of interest then hmmm.
|
|
|
Post by adamrocks on Oct 23, 2016 19:09:24 GMT -5
Nic @nicolec42 5h5 hours ago Great pictures don't need adapting (but I couldn't resist) @therealmickrock @adamlambert
|
|
|
Post by adamrocks on Oct 23, 2016 19:17:41 GMT -5
Ellie G. elliegf 1h1 hour ago loved how @adamlambert pushed all of his contestants a bit further - he's killing that judging thing #xfactorau Awesome!
|
|
|
Post by 4EverAdam on Oct 23, 2016 20:06:54 GMT -5
|
|
seashell
Member
totally easy
Posts: 1,461
Location:
|
Post by seashell on Oct 23, 2016 20:42:55 GMT -5
I finally watched the whole of episode10.. I surely don't feel it's fair that Mel could pick more than 1 from any category..it should have been a rule 1 from each group. Especially since they are eliminating 1 from each category..so now either Maddie or vlado will get an extra week ..hmmmm But it is what it is.. finally I don't really care for Chynna ..she sing well I guess but I haven't cared for the songs she has done or even how she sings them.. but I guess I am in the minority..eh..lol ..but it's all just my opinion..
|
|
|
Post by svca on Oct 23, 2016 20:49:12 GMT -5
I finally watched the whole of episode10.. I surely don't feel it's fair that Mel could pick more than 1 from any category..it should have been a rule 1 from each group. Especially since they are eliminating 1 from each category..so now either Maddie or vlado will get an extra week ..hmmmm But it is what it is.. finally I don't really care for Chynna ..she sing well I guess but I haven't cared for the songs she has done or even how she sings them.. but I guess I am in the minority..eh..lol ..but it's all just my opinion.. I'm confused....didn't Mel just pick one from each category? I know Vlado was from Adam's group, Beatz was from Iggy's group, wasn't Maddie from Guy's group? Or were Vlado and Maddie both from Adam's group? Lol, I'm confused....nothing new here. I definitely liked Aya better than Beatz, they did a good job in this round....their harmonies are good. Had to laugh at Adam's wardrobe comment. For eliminations I'm going to say Natalia from Adam's group, Timmy from Guy's group, either Vlado or Maddie from Mel's and the boy group from Iggy's.
|
|