9.25.13 QAL from iHRMF Played on Radio in NYC
Sept 25, 2013 15:29:46 GMT -5
Post by toofragile on Sept 25, 2013 15:29:46 GMT -5
Why are people surprised by what Avicii said? I posted all this exactly this way 5 days ago. And got chewed out here at Adamtopia over it. It was obvious that this is how it happened.
Avicii thought that a demo recording was next step. Nile didn't, and went out on his own.
Avicii liked what he heard the next day and accepted the terms that came with the deal.
And yes, I do believe that Adam at minimum reworked some lyrics. Some phrases sound very 'Adam-ish'.
But if you want to discuss Adam as a songwriter, this is not the right example to choose, because here he came in at the back end of the whole process. There are plenty of other examples, where Adam did much more and was there for the beginning.
And while I like that classic rock gives Adam some love here, I do think that Carol (the DJ) could have moderated her critique a bit. His songs are not bad, he does not deserve that. She could have said that she did not like them, rather than universally diss them.
There are lots of gems on his albums (both FYE and TSP). And I really like Avicii's album, but if I compare True in originality to Trespassing, then I think that Trespassing can totally hold its own.
What I do agree with, is that Adam has yet to write or record a timeless song that we will listen to in 50 years. One like WWTLF, or even a WWRY stomper or a dance hit.
Somehow he has been close with lots of his, but just not quite there and the luck of radio support did not come his way to lift one of the almost great ones up to that level of fame that top 10 songs tend to enjoy, whether they deserve it or not.
And, to end with another topic I regularly get flack for on this board. I do think that the reason Adam is close, but just not quite there in his songwriting is because he cannot ground himself in an instrument to give him the necessary support. He has to translate what he wants with words and then take what another person echos back and work from that. He will win, once he fixes that.
It takes about 6 weeks to learn guitar to a level that you can support yourself with accords. It's not that difficult or time consuming to learn the basics.
It takes years to learn guitar such that you can perform professionally. Adam will never need to do that. He can always leave it to others. But if he wants to win as a song-writer he needs to fill that gap to support his writing process. YMMV