3.1.12 CW Campaign Extended, Adam in Denver

I don't know. I think a few comments such as these, made me think that it maybe was Adam.

That said, I've always thought of Idol having a secondary purpose as a sort of music-education hour. With fewer schools able to afford music programs, a lot of kids -- and those in the key demo -- don't understand where the music they're listening to came from and from what it borrows. They probably know Jay-Z and Kanye West's "Otis" but might never have heard of Otis Redding. In that sense, maybe skewing older isn't such a bad thing.


He (Simon Cowell) obviously knew the show, and I listened to him in that respect, but it's a lot different when you're taking criticism from a Steven Tyler -- if he were to offer any. And there's the problem: Everybody needs support, but the harsh reality is, if these acts want to be in this business, they're going to have to get a few lashings. To regain credibility, Idol needs critical feedback from the judges and critiques that are spot-on.

But after reading it again, yeah maybe it's not Adam. It sounds a little too harsh in some areas.

I dunno, it doesn't necessarily read like the "mystery person" WAS judged by Steven...could be from any season.

The only thing I thought might indicate it wasn't Adam was the "berating" business. Was Adam ever berated? Even when the judges (Simon) tried to give negative feedback - it was hardly "berating".

Do you think it could be that goofy Chris whateverhislastname was? He seemed to love giving AI advice. LOL!


mika.....lovely idea. Perhaps offering it as an incentive - ie: the next 10 (or whatever) donations will be entered into a draw for the magazine? I dunno.

I've never read anything Daughtry wrote, but I agree with those who say it sounds like Chris Sligh. He's always spouting off as if he knows all there is to know.